Home › Services › Repair vs replacement

Problem guide

Repair or replace? A decision framework for South Florida systems

The repair-or-replace decision is not one number. It is the age of the system, the refrigerant it uses, the cost of the repair relative to a new system, the condition of the ducts and the house, and how long you expect to stay. A 12-year-old system with a failed capacitor is a repair. A 16-year-old R-22 system with a leaking indoor coil is usually a replacement conversation.

  • Independent referral service
  • No charge to homeowners
  • One contractor receives your request
  • No ratings or paid placements

Request a callback

Describe the symptom and your ZIP. One contractor receives it if one serves your ZIP.

No charge to submit. We do not sell your request. If no participating contractor serves your ZIP yet, we will tell you and will not share it with anyone else.

Symptoms

  • A repair quote that is a large fraction of a replacement quote.
  • Repeated repairs within a year or two.
  • A refrigerant that is expensive or being phased down.
  • Rooms that were never balanced even when the system was new (an original sizing or duct problem).
  • A compressor failure on an older system.

Safe checks you can do

  • Write down the model number, the serial number, the refrigerant type and the installation year.
  • Ask for the repair diagnosis in writing, including the part and the labor.
  • Ask for a replacement quote with the same capacity and the same duct work, plus any duct repairs separately.
  • Compare the total cost of ownership over the next five years, not just the sticker price.
  • Ask whether the indoor coil, the line set and the drain pan are included in a replacement quote.
Stop and call a technician if: Do not approve a replacement on the same visit as a repair diagnosis without a written second number. A second quote is normal and worth the time on a purchase this size.

Likely causes

  • Age and refrigerant — R-22 systems face high refrigerant costs. A leaking R-22 coil is often the point to replace.
  • Repair frequency — Two or more significant repairs in two years signals declining reliability.
  • Compressor failure — The compressor is the most expensive single component. On an older system, replacement often wins.
  • Duct and envelope problems — A new system connected to leaking ducts will not deliver the promised comfort or savings.
  • Efficiency — A new system may use less electricity, but the payback depends on run time, rates and the house.

What a repair involves

There is no single formula. A practical rule used by many contractors: if the repair is under a third of a replacement cost and the system is under ten years old, repair. If the system is over 12 to 15 years old, uses R-22, or has had repeated repairs, compare carefully. Get both numbers in writing before deciding.

Typical South Florida cost ranges

WorkPublished typical rangeNotes
Typical repair range (most jobs)$150–$650Both cited South Florida guides give this overall band for common repairs.
Compressor replacement$1,000–$3,000
Full system replacement$4,000–$8,000+Home size, efficiency, duct work and line-set condition drive the range.

Source: AC Service Pro (South Florida contractor cost guide), published 2026-07-13; Koala Coolin (South Florida contractor cost guide), published 2026-07-12. Both guides publish installed price ranges for South Florida; neither states its sample size. These are ranges, not quotes. The contractor sets the actual price after inspecting the system, and you approve it before work begins. See the cost guide methodology.

Seasonal context

Replacement decisions often get rushed during a heat wave. A system that fails in August can be repaired to get through the season and replaced in the shoulder months when scheduling is easier.

Where to go next

Find your city · Cost guide methodology · What to check before you call · All services

How a request is handled

Your request includes the symptom, your ZIP code, how soon you need help and the best time to reach you. If a participating contractor covers your ZIP, that one contractor receives it.

If no participating contractor covers the ZIP yet, we tell you and your request is not shared with anyone else.

We do not promise an arrival time. The contractor confirms availability with you directly.

Questions

How long should an AC last in Florida?

Many systems last 10 to 15 years in South Florida, with run time and maintenance making a large difference. Coastal salt air and long cooling seasons shorten the range for some homes.

Is a higher SEER rating always worth it?

Not always. The savings depend on run time, electricity rates, duct condition and the price difference. Ask for the estimated annual energy use, not just the rating.

Should I replace the indoor coil with the outdoor unit?

Mismatched coils can reduce efficiency and reliability. Ask the contractor to explain the match and the warranty for both parts.

Request a callback

One contractor, if one serves your ZIP. No charge to you.

Request a callback

Tell us what is wrong. If a participating contractor serves your ZIP code, your request goes to that one contractor.

No charge to submit. We do not sell your request. If no participating contractor serves your ZIP yet, we will tell you and will not share it with anyone else.

ACFixIt is an independent referral service. We do not perform heating, ventilation or air-conditioning work and we do not quote prices for work. The contractors who respond are independent businesses that set their own prices, schedules and terms. A contractor's Florida license number is shown on this site only after it has been verified in the state's public license lookup. Nothing on this site is an offer of contracting services by ACFixIt.

No charge to homeowners. Your request is shared with one participating contractor for your ZIP code, never sold or resold. Privacy · Terms